1885 - 1916
CPL David Wallace Crawford
1887 - 1916
Lce-Corpl John Joseph Nickle
1894 - 1916
Pte 17911 Morton Neill
1897 - 1916
Lieut Edward Stanley Ashcroft
1883 - 1918
Pte 51561 Abraham Goldstone

- Age: Unknown.
- From: Montreal, Canada
- Regiment: The King's (Liverpool Regiment) 17th Btn
- K.I.A Thursday 12th October 1916
- Commemorated at: Warlencourt Brit Cem
Panel Ref: V.A.22
The identity of Pte Abraham Goldstone is at present unknown as there are few clues:- SDGW state he was born in Montreal, Canada and resided in Liverpool, this resource is often incorrect.
However, there are two possible passenger records for Abraham Goldstone:-
June 1900 there is a 22 year old Abraham Goldstone, born Germany, who sailed from Liverpool for Quebec aboard the SS Vancouver.
August 1906 there is a 28 year old Abram Goldstone, single and a Tailor, who sailed for Quebec aboard the SS Tunisian.
He enlisted in Liverpool and served initially with the 1/6th Battalion of The King’s Liverpool Regiment as Private 3752. He embarked from Folkestone on 15th July 1916 on board the S.S. Princess Victoria. He joined 24 Infantry Base Depot on arrival on 16th July before joining 11 Entrenching Battalion on 02nd August and was attached to 17th Battalion K.L.R. on 05th August 1916. He was given 7 days Field Punishment No.1 for not complying with an order on 09th August 1916 and was posted to C Company of the 17th Battalion K.L.R. from 05th September 1916 as Private 51561.
He was initially reported as wounded and missing in action on the 12th October 1916 during the Battle of the Transloy Ridges which was part of the ongoing Somme Offensive. His war gratuity of £4-10 suggests that he enlisted in June or July of 1915. His medal roll shows service only with 17th Battalion.
His death was subsequently assumed to have taken place on that date.
17th Bn War Diary: Battle of Transloy Ridge –
11-10-16 - Gird Trench/Gird Support – Battalion in front line and support trenches. British bombardment of enemy front line system commenced about midday. Hostile shelling was intermittent throughout the day.
12-10-16 - Our bombardment continued. Enemy reply weak. 2.5 p.m. Zero hour. Attack on German front line system commenced. Enemy wire was found to be uncut and attack was unsuccessful. Hostile machine gun fire was very heavy and caused many casualties. Battalion H.Q. and Support Trench were heavily shelled throughout afternoon and evening. […] During this action all communication had to be carried out by runners and carrier pigeons as all wires were being continually cut by enemy shelling.
Casualties: 5 officers killed, 5 officers wounded, 38 OR killed, about 225 OR wounded/missing etc.
Graham Maddocks, in “Liverpool Pals” p.140, adds:
“As the whistle blew, the 17th Battalion left its trenches to move forward. […] As soon as the attacking waves left their trenches the enemy artillery began to register on them, and at the same time, the defending infantry commenced a murderous rain of fire. […] Although their numbers had been depleted by the British bombardment, they were trained and experienced soldiers, well dug in on high ground, and for the most part, looking out on uncut wire. As such, it was virtually impossible for them to miss the City Battalion men struggling to advance in the mud towards them. The 17th Battalion, on the left, was particularly badly hit, as its portion of No Man’s Land contained a slight rise in the ground, and as the troops emerged onto it they were silhouetted against the sky and became easy targets. Those on the left of the attack, who managed to avoid the hail of bullets and make it to the German wire, then found that it was totally uncut, and thus trapped, they too became easy targets, to be picked off almost at the enemy’s will. It was hardly surprising that, seeing the first waves being wiped out, some of the following waves turned back and made for their start lines. These lines were now packed with other waves of troops, however, and the fleeing men added to the congestion already there, and became easy prey for the German gunners. There is some evidence also, to suggest that at this stage, the British trenches were also being hit by their own heavy artillery shells which were falling short.”
Abraham now rests at Warlencourt British Cemetery, France.
Warlencourt Cemetery is entirely a concentration cemetery, begun late in 1919 when graves were brought in from small cemeteries and the battlefields of Warlencourt and Le Sars. The Graves Registration form shows graves from “Le Sars 6/1, 6/2, Hexham Road, Seven Elms”.
Graves were brought in from the original cemeteries at Hexham Road (Le Sars), and Seven Elms (Flers), as well as over 3,000 British graves due to the fighting which took place around the Butte de Warlencourt from the autumn of 1916 to the spring of 1917, and again in the German advance and retreat of 1918. The cemetery now contains 3,505 Commonwealth burials and commemorations of the First World War, 1,823 of which are unidentified.
His death was subsequently assumed to have taken place on 12th October 1916 as reported in the Liverpool Daily Post on 04th August 1917:
PREVIOUSLY REPORTED WOUNDED & MISSING, NOW
REPORTED KILLED.
Liverpool R. - Goldstone, 51561, A;
Soldiers Effects went to cousins Bessie and Rosie Goldwater. No Pension record found.
His medals were returned for disposal (Medal Roll).
Bessie Goldwater appears on the Liverpool Electoral Roll from 1918-1920 at 44 Mill Street, Toxteth and 87 Oxford Street, Liverpool. She is not recorded on the 1921 census but we are fairly sure she sailed from Liverpool on the 13th January 1920 aboard the S.S. Carmania bound for New York. She was married, aged 51, and her last place of residence was shown as Liverpool. Her next of kin contact was her mother "Ester" Goldstone of 273 New Bury Road, Manchester. There are three other Goldwater's sailing with her, Myer, (14), Lionel, (13) and Abram, (11), all last resident Liverpool and using the same next of kin contact. All four were heading for Los Angeles, California.
Ester Goldstone is probably the 63 year old "Esther" Goldstone, born Poland, who was recorded living with her husband of 45 years, Jacob, at 15 Moreton Street, Cheetham, Manchester on the 1911 Census of England & Wales. Jacob was also aged 63 and born Poland and was working as a Tailor. The union has produced 12 children, all then still alive.
Bessie Goldwater on the Census of England & Wales:-
1891. Aged 23, born Poland and married to Joseph Samuel Goldwater, aged 29, a Tailor, born Poland. The couple were recorded in one of the two households at 132 Moreton Street, Cheetham Manchester. Living with them are their children Harry, (4, born Manchester), Lily, (2) and Ruby, (8) months, both born Ireland.
1901. Age 32, born "London" and married to Joseph Goldwater, (39, Master Tailor, born Poland) and living at 29 Ashton Street, Liverpool. In the household are children Harry, (14, Tailor, born Manchester), Lily, (12), Rebecca, (10), Rosa, (8), Adelaide, (6), Dora, (5) - all born Ireland, Gertrude, (3), Fanny, (1) and David, (6 months) - all three born Liverpool. The household also runs to a live in servant.
1911. Aged 42, born Germany and married to Joseph Goldwater, (50, Tailor, born Germany), for 25 years. The union has produced 14 children, of which 12 were then still alive. The family were living at 38 Stafford Street, Liverpool. Children still single and living at home are Ida, (17, Tailoress), Dora, (15) - both born Cork, Ireland, Gertie, (13), Fanny, (11) and David, (10) - all three born Liverpool, and Myer, (7, born Cork), Lionel, (6) and Aby, (male, 3) both born Liverpool.
Bessie’s family at 273 Bury New Road in 1921 are:-
Abraham Goldstone b.1887 Manchester
Esther Goldstone b.1850 Poland
Samuel Goldstone b.1877 Manchester
Abraham is mentioned in the 'British Jewry Roll of Honour, 1914-1918' and also remembered in the Canadian First World War Book of Remembrance.
Grateful thanks are extended to Kevin Shannon the author of the book The Liverpool Rifles for providing details of Abraham's service with the 6th Rifles.
We currently have no further information on Abraham Goldstone, If you have or know someone who may be able to add to the history of this soldier, please contact us.
Killed On This Day.
(108 Years this day)Sunday 16th June 1918.
Pte 57615 Fred William Preddy
23 years old
(105 Years this day)
Thursday 16th June 1921.
Captain Leonard George Duncan
43 years old
