1885 - 1916
CPL David Wallace Crawford
1887 - 1916
Lce-Corpl John Joseph Nickle
1894 - 1916
Pte 17911 Morton Neill
1897 - 1916
Lieut Edward Stanley Ashcroft
1883 - 1918
Pte 24932 James McDonald

- Age: 30
- From: Liverpool
- Regiment: The King's (Liverpool Regiment) 17th Btn
- K.I.A Wednesday 12th July 1916
- Commemorated at: Bernafay Wood Brit Cem
Panel Ref: G.46
James was the husband of Ann Elizabeth Mabb whom he married in St. Marie’s, Southport, on 16th April 1913, his wife was from Hull and their son John David was born in the City on 02nd February 1914. A daughter Catherine was born in Hull on 31st March 1916, when James’ battalion was on the Somme front. It is not likely that James ever met his daughter.
He enlisted in Liverpool joining the 17th Battalion of The King's Liverpool Regiment as Private 24932. The War Gratuity of £6 suggests that James served for 18 months, enlisting in about January 1915.
He was billeted at Prescot Watch Factory, he trained there and also at Knowsley Hall. On 30th April 1915 the 17th Battalion alongside the other three Pals battalions left Liverpool via Prescot Station for further training at Belton Park, Grantham. They remained here until September 1915 when they reached Larkhill Camp on Salisbury Plain. He arrived in France on 7th November 1915.
As a member of the 17th Battalion he was part of the liberation of the village of Montauban on 1st July 1916. The Liverpool Pals were then involved in the action to clear Trones Wood of the Germans.
The murderous fighting that went on inside Trones Wood rendered it impossible to put specific dates on some of the casualties which is why many of the 17th Battalion losses have been bracketed as killed in action between 10th – 12th July 1916. The conditions are best described in the following passage from Everard Wyrall’s book The History of The King’s Regiment (Liverpool) Volume II.
The remembrance of Trones Wood in July 1916 to those who passed through it is of a noisome, horrible place, of a tangled mass of trees and undergrowth which had been tossed and flung about in frightful confusion by the shells of both sides. Of the ghastly dead which lay about in all directions, and of DEATH, lurking in every hole and corner with greedy hands ready to snatch the lives of the unwary. The place was a Death trap, and although the attacks were made with great determination, the presence of snipers who could not be detected and often fired into the backs of our men made the clearing of the wood impossible.
James was killed in action, aged 30, and was buried close to where he fell, after the Armistice, when graves were concentrated, his body was removed and reinterred in Bernafay Wood British Cemetery, where he now rests.
The cemetery was begun by a dressing station in August 1916 and used as a front-line cemetery until the following April. It contained at the Armistice 284 burials but was then increased when graves were brought in from Bernafay Wood North Cemetery and from the battlefields immediately east of the wood. Bernafay Wood British Cemetery now contains 945 burials and commemorations of the First World War, 417 of which are unidentified.
He was originally declared Missing, and his family did not learn of his fate until the end of the year. As reported in the Hull Daily Mail on 22nd December 1916,
“Previously reported Missing now reported Killed, King’s Liverpool Regiment, McDonald, 24932, J. (Hull).”
His son was two and his daughter just three months old when James was killed.
“Killed in action, July 12, 1916, Private James McDonald, K.L.R., beloved husband of A. E. McDonald (née Mabb), 35 Liddell Street.”
He was reported as killed in the press on 23rd December 1916
James earned his three medals. His effects, War Gratuity and Pension went to his widow Ann Elizabeth, at 35 Liddell Street, Hull.In 1939 his widow Ann, now 56, son John and daughter Catherine, as well as her mother Mary C. Mabb, are living at 44 Kirklands Road in Hull. John, 25, is a bus conductor, Catherine, 23, is listed as ‘cripple’. His widow Ann died in Hull in 1970, aged 87. His son John died in 1996. His daughter Catherine appears to have lived until 2007.
James is commemorated on the following Memorials:
Hall of Remembrance, Liverpool Town Hall Panel 20
James is also commemorated in the book, "Clan Donald Roll of Honour 1914-1918".
The dedication reads,
"At the Call of Duty from the Four Corners of the Earth Came the Children of the Clan to Battle for the Right.
In many graves in many lands their gallant bodies sleep. Their spirits rest with God.
To their loved ones, bereaved of them, this Roll proclaims the price the Clan hath paid.
A token it is also, bringing pride to lighten grief for lives so well laid down.
For this we know: They yet shall live again."
We currently have no further information on James McDonald. If you have or know someone who may be able to add to the history of this soldier, please contact us.
89th Brigade On This Day.
110 Years Ago.The Battle of the Transloy Ridges begins. more....
Killed On This Day.
(110 Years this day)Monday 16th October 1916.
Pte 22929 Edward Bird
19 years old
(110 Years this day)
Monday 16th October 1916.
Pte 16795 William Frederick Collister
23 years old
(109 Years this day)
Tuesday 16th October 1917.
L/Cpl 49038 Ernest Yardley
31 years old
(108 Years this day)
Wednesday 16th October 1918.
Pte 85187 James Hoy
31 years old
(107 Years this day)
Thursday 16th October 1919.
Pte 36438 Hugh Morris
23 years old
